In restorative dentistry, removing less tissue does not mean doing less. It means preserving more options for the future.
For a long time, treating a caries lesion essentially meant removing the affected tissue and restoring the cavity.
Today, minimal intervention dentistry proposes a change in thinking: preserving dental structure whenever biologically possible, controlling the disease, and intervening in a manner commensurate with the risk and activity of the lesion.
This does not mean “not treating.”
It means treating the disease without sacrificing healthy structure unnecessarily.
Before deciding on the intervention, it is necessary to understand what is happening with the lesion.
Caries is a dynamic disease, and a lesion can be active or inactive, in addition to presenting different depths and clinical characteristics.
The consensus of the International Caries Consensus Collaboration recommends that the therapeutic decision consider lesion activity, caries risk and depth, avoiding unnecessary removal of healthy dental tissue (SCHWENDICKE et al., 2016).
Therefore, in the face of an injury, the most interesting question is:
“What is the smallest intervention capable of controlling the disease and preserving the structure?”
This is one of the most important changes in contemporary dentistry.
In deep lesions, complete removal of the decayed tissue near the pulp may increase the risk of pulp exposure.
Selective removal seeks to leave affected dentin near the pulp when this allows to reduce the risk of exposure and perform a restoration with good sealing.
A systematic review and meta-analysis showed that selective or staged removal, compared to non-selective removal, significantly reduces the risk of pulp exposure in teeth with deep caries (SCHWENDICKE et al., 2013). (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)
This represents a paradigm shift: is no longer “remove everything at any cost”. It is: to remove what is necessary to control the disease, preserving as much of the structure as possible.
Here is a key difference.
Minimal intervention is not minimal attention.
If there is an active lesion, treatment needs to control the factors that allow its progression.
This may involve biofilm control, fluorides, behavioral changes, diet control, follow-up, and, when indicated, restorative intervention.
The contemporary approach to caries management recommends combining non-operative and operativestrategies, choosing the intervention according to the patient's activity, depth and individual risk (SCHWENDICKE et al., 2016).
Therefore:
Preserving tissue without controlling the disease is not minimal intervention. It's undertreatment.
There is an important paradox in Dentistry:
restoring a tooth solves a current problem, but creates a restoration that will also need to be followed up.
Restorations can present with fracture, wear, maladaptation, secondary caries, and other complications over time.
A systematic review of the life cycle of restorations showed that replacing restorations can result in a progressive loss of tooth structure, especially when each replacement involves additional tissue removal (BLUM et al., 2018).
It is called “restorative cycle”:
injury → restoration → failure → replacement → major restoration → new failure → new replacement.
Therefore, when an existing restoration has a localized problem, the question should not always be:
“Do we need to change everything?”
It could be:
“Is it possible to repair?”
Minimally invasive dentistry has also changed the way you think about restorations that have minor flaws.
In certain situations, repair, sealing, or localized remodeling may avoid unnecessary removal of an entire restoration and more tooth structure.
A systematic review on repair versus replacement of restorations found evidence that repair may be a clinically acceptable alternative in certain situations, although the quality of the evidence varies depending on the type of restoration and clinical setting (HEINTZE; ROUSSON, 2012).
This does not mean that every restoration must be repaired.
Means that replacement should not be an automatic response to the first fault found.
Before removing or replacing, ask:
□ Is the disease active?
□ How much healthy tissue will be removed?
□ Can the injury be controlled without surgical intervention?
□ Is selective removal appropriate for the depth of the lesion?
□ Does an existing restoration really need to be completely replaced?
□ Is it possible to repair a localized fault?
□ Is the patient at risk of further injury?
□ How will today's decision affect treatment possibilities in the future?
This last question is perhaps the most important.
Why does a tooth not finish its treatment in today's restoration.
Minimum intervention does not mean always choosing the smallest procedure.
It means choosing the intervention proportional to the problem.
Sometimes this means not restoring.
Sometimes it means selectively remove.
Sometimes it means repairing rather than replacing.
And sometimes, when the destruction is extensive or the biological hazard demands it, a broader restorative intervention will be necessary.
The principle remains the same:
preserve dental structure, control the disease and maintain as many therapeutic options as possible for the future.
In practice, perhaps the most modern question in Dentistry is not:
“How much tissue can I remove?”
But:
“How much tissue can I preserve without compromising disease control and treatment results?”
This is the essence of minimal intervention.
SCHWENDICKE, Falk et al. Managing carious lesions: consensus recommendations on carious tissue removal. Advances in Dental Research, v. 28, no. 2, p. 58-67, 2016. DOI: 10.1177/0022034516639271.
SCHWENDICKE, Falk; DÖRFER, Christian E.; PARIS, Sebastian. Incomplete caries removal: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Dental Research, v. 92, no. 4, p. 306-314, 2013. DOI: 10.1177/0022034513477425.
SCHWENDICKE, Falk et al. Managing carious lesions: consensus recommendations on carious tissue removal. Advances in Dental Research, 2016.
HEINTZE, Siegward D.; ROUSSON, V. Clinical effectiveness of direct class II restorations—a meta-analysis. Journal of Adhesive Dentistry, 2012.
BLUM, I. R.; LYNCH, C.D.; WILSON, N. H. F. Factors influencing repair versus replacement of dental restorations: a review of the literature. Dental Materials, 2018.
INNES, N. P. T. et al. Managing carious lesions: consensus recommendations on terminology. Advances in Dental Research, 2016
Explore outros conteúdos, aprofunde seus conhecimentos e descubra novas possibilidades para sua carreira.