Not all pain that the patient locates in a tooth originates from that tooth. Recognizing this difference can avoid irreversible procedures and completely change the way the case is handled.
Odontogenic pain is extremely common in clinical practice and, most of the time, is actually related to dental or periodontal structures. The problem appears when the perceived location of the pain and its true origin do not coincide.
Myofascial pain, temporomandibular disorders, neuropathic changes, sinus diseases and neurovascular pain can manifest as “toothache” (THOMAS et al., 2026; ZAIDAN et al., 2020).
And here is the great clinical challenge:
Treating the site of pain without identifying its origin may mean treating the wrong tooth.
The location reported by the patient is important information, but should not be used alone to establish the diagnosis.
Orofacial pain can be referred, causing the patient to perceive the sensation in a region different from that in which the painful stimulus originates. Therefore, clinical history, examination, pulp tests and imaging exams need to be interpreted together (EHRMANN, 2002).
A classic example is the patient who arrives saying:
“It’s this molar here.”
But, when investigating, the professional does not find a change compatible with the intensity, duration or pattern of the pain.
At this time, the absence of a convincing dental cause is also a diagnostic finding.
Some patterns do not match well with a typical odontogenic origin.
Among the warning signs described in the literature are:
persistent and little variable pain;
burning sensation;
poorly localized pain;
multiple teeth involved;
absence of a compatible dental cause;
persistence of pain after adequate dental treatment;
lack of response after anesthesia of the suspected tooth (OKESON, 2000; ZAKRZEWSKA; MCMILLAN, 2011).
This does not mean that any of these signs rule out a dental origin.
It means that they should increase attention to the differential diagnosis.
The spectrum of differential diagnoses is wide.
Myofascial pain may be referred to teeth.
Changes in the temporomandibular joint can produce pain perceived in the dental region.
Neuralgias and other neuropathic pain can present very different characteristics from conventional pulp pain.
Sinusopathy can also produce referred pain to upper teeth.
And there are even less intuitive causes, including neurovascular pain and, in specific situations, pain of cardiac origin (THOMAS et al., 2026; SCHAMES et al., 2016).
Therefore, when the history and examination do not “close” with the tooth indicated by the patient, reasoning needs to expand.
This is perhaps the most important point for clinical practice.
If the professional does not identify the source of the pain, but decides to treat the tooth just because it seems to be the most likely, they may end up carrying out a procedure that does not treat the real cause.
This is particularly relevant in Endodontics.
A systematic review found that, among studies that evaluated patients with persistent pain after endodontic treatment, a relevant portion of cases had a non-odontogenic origin; in a pooled analysis, 56% of cases evaluated for etiology were considered non-odontogenic (NIXDORF et al., 2010).
In an investigation by the Dental Clinical Research Network, among patients who presented pain six months after endodontic treatment, 42% were diagnosed with non-odontogenic pain, with reported pain associated with temporomandibular disorder being the most frequent non-odontogenic cause in that group (NIXDORF et al., 2015).
This does not mean that endodontic treatment causes non-odontogenic pain.
It means that the persistence of pain after treatment requires diagnostic reassessment, and not necessarily another procedure on the same tooth.
The safest clinical reasoning begins before choosing the procedure.
Is the history of pain compatible with the odontogenic hypothesis?
Does the clinical examination confirm this hypothesis?
Do pulp tests reproduce or explain the complaint?
Are the radiographic findings compatible?
Is there a coherent relationship between the findings and the intensity of pain?
Does local anesthesia change pain?
Is there any information that contradicts the initial hypothesis?
When these answers do not converge, perhaps the most appropriate decision is not to intervene immediately and expand the investigation.
A 2020 review on the differential diagnosis of toothache highlights that recognizing non-odontogenic conditions is essential to avoid unnecessary and irreversible dental treatments (ZAIDAN et al., 2020).
And a 2024 review reinforces that patients with persistent dentoalveolar pain need systematic investigation of odontogenic and non-odontogenic causes before new irreversible treatments (KOLBINSON; GOULET, 2024).
When the patient points to a tooth, do not immediately think:
“What procedure does this tooth need?”
Think first:
“What explains this pain?”
Because there is a huge difference between:
locating the pain
and
identifying its origin.
The tooth may actually be the source.
But it can also just be the place where the patient notices pain that arose elsewhere in the orofacial system.
The best treatment for misdiagnosed pain may be no dental treatment at all — at least until its origin is clarified.
And perhaps this is one of the most important skills of a clinician:
knowing not only when to treat, but when to stop, investigate and reconsider the diagnosis.
THOMAS, Davis C. et al. Toothaches of Non-odontogenic Origin. Dental Clinics of North America, vol. 70, n. 1, p. 209-224, 2026. DOI: 10.1016/j.cden.2025.07.013.
ZAIDAN, N. et al. Differential diagnosis of toothache to prevent erroneous and unnecessary dental treatment. Journal of Oral Rehabilitation, 2020. DOI: 10.1111/joor.12946.
EHRMANN, E. H. The diagnosis of referred orofacial dental pain. Australian Endodontic Journal, vol. 28, no. 2, p. 75-81, 2002. DOI: 10.1111/j.1744-4477.2002.tb00388.x.
NIXDORF, Donald R. et al. Frequency of nonodontogenic pain after endodontic therapy: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Endodontics, 2010. DOI: 10.1016/j.joen.2010.06.020.
NIXDORF, Donald R. et al. Differential diagnoses for persistent pain after root canal treatment: a study in the National Dental Practice-based Research Network. Journal of Endodontics, 2015.
KOLBINSON, Dean A.; GOULET, Jean-Paul Name. Persistent Toothache Despite Multiple Dental-related Treatments: How Could this Be? Journal of the Canadian Dental Association, vol. 90, 2024.
SCHAMES, Scott E. et al. Nonodontogenic Sources of Dental Pain. Journal of the California Dental Association, vol. 44, no. 8, p. 507-513, 2016.
Explore outros conteúdos, aprofunde seus conhecimentos e descubra novas possibilidades para sua carreira.