In an adhesive restoration, it is tempting to think that success depends primarily on choosing a good adhesive system.
In reality, adhesion to dentin is a result of the interaction between substrate, adhesive strategy, material composition, operative technique, and clinical conditions. And that is precisely why two professionals using the same adhesive can obtain different results.
The first key difference is understanding that adhering to dentin is more complex than adhering to enamel.
Dentin has a higher organic content and is naturally moist, in addition to having dentinal tubules and a structure that varies according to tissue depth and condition. When the tooth is prepared, it still forms at smear layer, a layer of waste resulting from instrumentation that modifies the surface available for adhesion.
That is: even before applying the adhesive, there are already variables capable of interfering with the interaction between the adhesive system and the substrate.
Adhesive systems can work using different strategies including etch-and-rinse and self-etch.
With so-called universal adhesives, the practitioner can choose different modes of application. But beware of the idea that there is a universally superior protocol.
A meta-analysis of laboratory studies found differences between strategies depending on adhesive and substrate composition. For some universal adhesives, pre-conditioning of the enamel can improve adhesion, while the results in dentin are more dependent on the system used. And when we look at clinical outcomes, the story may be different.
A meta-analysis of clinical trials found better retention, marginal adaptation, and less marginal discoloration for certain applications in etch-and-rinse compared to self-etch.
Therefore:
Do not choose the strategy just for the fame of the protocol. Consider the patch, substrate, and clinical situation.
One of the biggest sources of error is to treat the application of the adhesive as a mechanical step: applies → hold → blows → photopolymerizes.
But adhesive systems need proper time and interaction with the dentinal surface.
A systematic review and meta-analysis found increased bond strength of universal adhesives to dentin with strategies such as longer application time, friction technique (scrubbing), application of multiple layers, longer photopolymerization time and some additional strategies. The authors, however, emphasize the high heterogeneity of the studies, many of them in vitro.
This brings a simple clinical message:
The adhesive needs to be applied according to the manufacturer's protocol — and not according to the operator's hurry.
Dentin should not be treated as a surface that simply needs to be “dry.”
After conditioning, especially in etch-and-rinse systems, humidity control becomes critical. Excessively dry dentin can alter the condition of the collagen network.
Excessive water, on the other hand, can hinder the proper infiltration of the adhesive components and favor their dilution. The goal is to obtain a surface compatible with the adhesive system used.
And here there is an important rule:
There is no universal “ideal moisture”. There is the condition of substrate compatible with that adhesive strategy.
No two products classified as “universal adhesives” are necessarily the same.
They may differ in:
functional monomers;
production
concentration of components;
pH;
hydrophilic/hydrophobic character;
mechanism of interaction with tissues;
indication for use.
An important example is functional monomers capable of chemically interacting with components of the dental structure.
The current literature reinforces that the performance of universal adhesives is related to the composition and application strategy, and that the stability of the adhesive interface can vary between materials.
Therefore, “universal” does not mean “all work exactly the same way”.
We can summarize it in five major variables:
SUBSTRATE: Which dentine is being conditioned?
STRATEGY: How was this surface prepared?
MATERIAL: What is the composition and mechanism of action of the adhesive?
TECHNIQUE: Was the protocol executed correctly?
LONGEVITY: Does the interface remain stable over time?
The mistake is trying to find a single factor responsible for success. Adhesion is a chain.
If one step of this chain is compromised, the initial resistance obtained in the laboratory may not translate into clinical longevity.
Before restoring, don't just think:
“What adhesive will I use?”
Think:
What substrate do I have?
What strategy does this system recommend?
Do I need to selectively condition the enamel?
How should I treat the dentin?
Is the application time being respected?
How am I controlling humidity?
Is photopolymerization adequate?
Am I following the specific protocol of that product?
This change in reasoning is important because adhesion is not a property that comes ready within the vial.
It is clinically constructed.
The best available adhesive does not compensate for a poorly prepared surface, an inadequate protocol, or inconsistent execution.
CHEM, Huan et al. Comparison of bond strength of universal adhesives using different etching modes: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Dental Materials Journal, v. 41, n. 1, 2022. DOI: 10.4012/dmj.2021-111.
ROSA, Wellington L. O. et al. Bond strength of universal adhesives: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Dentistry, 2015. DOI: 10.1016/j.jdent.2015.04.003.
ELKAFFAS, Ali A.; HAMAMA, Hamdi H. H.; MAHMOUD, Salah H. Do universal adhesives promote bonding to dentin? A systematic review and meta-analysis. Restorative Dentistry & Endodontics, v. 43, no. 3, e29, 2018. DOI: 10.5395/rde.2018.43.e29.
MARCHESI, Giovanni et al. Universal dental adhesives: current status, laboratory testing, and clinical performance. Journal of Dentistry, 2019.
DEMIREL KARADUMAN, Yesim et al. Comparison of universal adhesives used in different etching modes on dentin bond strength: a systematic review and network meta-analysis. BMC Oral Health, 2026. DOI: 10.1186/s12903-026-08982-4.
Explore outros conteúdos, aprofunde seus conhecimentos e descubra novas possibilidades para sua carreira.